Why can’t we be friends?
I ended my relationship with Edwin Pomble when I finally got the courage to tell him that I’d been raped years before, and he probed relentlessly for more information, making me relive the event in excruciating detail for over an hour until I couldn’t stop crying, then screamed at me and told me I must’ve liked it.
Don’t ask me why I tried to be friends with him after that, but I did. I extended myself until I unraveled, trying to show him that although I couldn’t trust him enough to have the relationship we once had, I still cared about him and didn’t want to “throw him away”, as he put it.
It took him all of two weeks before he stopped apologizing and started resenting me for not taking him back. Sometimes I wondered: was I being too hard on him, being a bitch about the whole thing? He certainly thought so. But when I actually considered being together again I couldn’t stomach the thought. It didn’t matter how perverse and unyielding I was being, the breakup event had forever fractured the way I saw him, the way I felt about him. No part of me wanted him back.
So we tried the friendship thing. I made an honest go of it, but I don’t think he did. To him, our friendship was a purgatory he had to suffer through until I finally came to my senses and begged him to be my bride. The longer things went without that happening, the more resentful he became, and the more he pressured me to give him his way.
…
It is a frigid Saturday night. We’ve been broken up for a few months. The hemisphere has spun into a biting post-holiday winter gloom. My illness has been unkind to me for all of the newborn year so far: my headache raging and my joints complaining. I’ve been stuck indoors for a week, lonely and bored, feeling just better enough today to be restless. Edwin calls and invites me out to a karaoke bar a few blocks from his apartment, to come hang out with few of his friends. Great, I think. I can socialize with Edwin in a friend-type way on neutral territory with witnesses, all the post-breakup planets aligning perfectly for once. Plus, he’s been alluding recently to one of his friends being interested in him. I hope maybe it’s one of the chicks that will be at the bar that night. We can all hang out together and I can give them my unspoken seal of approval. I decide to get in non-pajama clothing for the first time all year and meet them.
10:30 PM. It shouldn’t be a shock that the bar’s crowded, being Saturday night and all. But Edwin seems to freeze up as soon as he sees how many people are there. He declares his intentions to leave. I want to stay, and tell him so. I damn well came to sing karaoke and have fun, not to go to Edwin’s place and sulk together, or whatever. So I stay and sing and have fun with a bunch of people I barely know.
But then he calls and leaves me a voicemail explaining how he had really been worried about me and that’s why he’d wanted to leave, and he wouldn’t have left if he’d known I was okay with it (note: we did talk about how he wanted to leave and how I wanted to stay before he left, so I suspect he’s trying to manipulate me somehow. But I’m pretty easy to manipulate, as we will see). But I start feeling like a bit of a prat. Maybe it was rude of me to stay at the bar when he didn’t want to. I don’t really know. So despite my “being alone with him” misgivings, I leave after a couple of hours of karaoke and stop by his place to prevent being a total jerk.
As soon as I climb the stairs to his second floor flat it’s clear he wants to have sex. With me. He’s really, really adamant about it and I in turn am really, really adamant about not wanting to. I tell him I don’t think of him in that way anymore, that I want to be friends and nothing more. Yes, I, sex fiend, am refusing sex! I try to leave. He grabs me, presses against me, then, rebuffed, starts going on about how horrible the rejection feels. He’s getting more and more passionate, getting upset, maybe getting angry. This flips a sort of switch with me. I can’t explain it very well. I tend to have problems putting my feelings above a guy’s feelings (especially if his feelings resemble anger) in a disagreement like this because for years any disagreement meant I was in major, violent trouble (see: my entire relationship with Reginald). Edwin seems angry to me, and my will collapses.
Fear crackles through my body, a response to things that have happened before as much as anything happening in the present. Adrenaline pumps into my bloodstream for no reason, I feel far away and small. The protests I was making moments ago seem like they came from someone else now, like I was reading from a fantastical script that I could never hope to really live.
“I’m sorry. I’m sorry. If you want, we can have sex,” I hear me say. The words are mechanical. I sigh as I say them. It is clear to us both that I absolutely do not want to.
He says, “Are you saying that because you think you’ll lose me if you don’t?”
“No,” I tell him, “I’m saying it because I don’t feel that I have the right to say no.” And that’s the simple truth. In that moment, I’m afraid not to give him his way, although I don’t really know why.
So he makes a big show of how he doesn’t want that. How he isn’t that guy. I’m still frightened, but I’m thankful. It’s exactly what I was hoping would happen if I told him the truth. I haven’t figured out yet how to not feel this fear but it’s not going to win tonight. My body is nominally mine for now. I head for the door. I hit the bottom of the stairs. My hand is on the door knob.
A split second before exiting I hear him say, “I’ve changed my mind. Come back .”
It feels like my blood’s been flash frozen and my skin’s been slapped with something cold, dead, ugly. I don’t know why I do it. I don’t know why I scale the stairs and numbly follow him into his bedroom. For some reason I don’t feel I have a choice.
It is the worst sex of all time, and I’ve had some bad sex. I just want it to be over. My cunt feels arid then raw. I hate how his sweat drips down on me. The condom breaks and he doesn’t notice until after. I can’t even make myself care. For some reason I just want to know that there aren’t any pieces of it stuck inside me. It’s all that matters now. As I ask him if they all came out with him, I choke the words out. He tells me it’s all there. The thin veil of senseless panic leaves me and I’m flooded with nausea. I excuse myself to go to the bathroom and quietly wretch into his toilet. As I leave, Edwin says he loves me. It sounds far away.
…
The next day I found a small, round scrap of latex inside me and snapped from numb to livid. Not even at him, really just at myself.
Jesus Christ. I’m not sure what to say except that he’s a complete ass, I don’t fault your actions, and I hope nothing like that happens to you again.
I’m very sorry to hear about the horrifying scenarios you’ve been through.
I about felt like throwing up myself by the end.
“He was an ass” doesn’t seem adequate. I’ve dealt with some fucking bastard manipulators in my life, but never at this kind of cost.
He is a manipulative, abusive person. And I hate that I can relate to the feeling of having no choice. Of having to say yes because you feel that you can’t say no. I know all too well what that feels like and I wish I didn’t. I’m sorry that you know what that feels like, too. <3
Thanks for commenting, everyone. Edwin called me the other day and was trying to be all friendly, so I wrote this to reinforce for myself the reason I don’t really want to be a part of his life, just in case he ends up making a “let’s be friends for reals” bid in the future. Disgust will help me stay strong, I’m sure.
Wow, this creep sounds a little bit like one of my exes. He had serious problems with trust, we had some fights, and I completely lost emotional interest in him over time. We were living together, so we tried to be friends after the breakup. At first he cooled down and it seemed like maybe it could work. One night he wouldn’t stop begging for sex. I actually didn’t mind fucking him but was annoyed by the manipulation and afraid he’d feel led on. After several hours I gave in, only after repeatedly telling him I had no feelings for him. I was so sleep deprived that my judgment was crap. He held the encounter against me later, of course.
Over the next couple weeks the ex got more and more passive aggressive and we had more fights. I started dating someone new. The ex flipped, I moved out. He’d considered the breakup a temporary test to endure until he won me back. He thought he had the right to another chance and demanded I give it to him. He began alternating between saying I was worst person in the world and saying he’d never love another and wanted me back. Things went downhill from there. I ended up having to file a restraining order and moved again further away.
So yeah, feel your pain.
I’m so sorry! Nobody deserves to be treated that way. I hope you blocked his number so he can no longer call you. Ugh.
That is truly horrible. My heart goes out to you. Nobody should ever have to go through a situation like that. By all means don’t just avoid Edwin, but all like him. *hugs*